11.10.2009

Jesus' Son




Billy Crudup and Samantha Morton in Jesus' Son (dir. Alison Maclean, 1999).



Billy Crudup and Jack Black.

Denis Johnson's 1992 book of short stories Jesus' Son not only leaves its narrator unnamed, but it leaves open to question whether this narrator is in fact the same from story to story. It's easy to see why so many readers assume it is. The voice throughout goes back and forth between various levels of heroin-addledness, which one can reasonably imagine as representing one person at different stages of deterioration or (partial) recovery. But it's never made explicit. This narrative structure is crucial to the book's power: the very notion of continuous identity is one of the commonplaces rendered unreliable or even moot by the destructive force of addiction. Similarly, even if we decide the speaker is the same, it's not clear that the order of the stories is chronological. They could well represent randomized memories of a life in irreparable disorder.

These are the main reasons that Alison Maclean's 1999 movie version utterly fails as a whole, despite the impressiveness of many of its parts. The decision to treat the book as a novel with an unequivocally consistent central character is disastrous (though it would have been equally disastrous to come down explicitly on the other possibility, that the characters are different, and it may be that the book is simply unfilmable). It's always a bad sign when a film adapted from a book relies heavily on voiceovers of speech lifted directly from the original text, and in this case the offense is particularly grave. Though probably no one could pull this off, Billy Crudup has no idea what to do with Johnson's gnomically elliptical prose. He tries to make it sound natural, even jaunty: big mistake. It's not natural, it's literary. It's not a script for performance, not a realistic facsimile of someone's interior monologue, but a deft superimposition of a pointed authorial sensibility onto characters who, if they were real, might well not even share much of that author's vocabulary. In the same way, the decision to render the discrete stories as a continuous arc of dramatic crisis eventuating in cathartic self-realization flattens out Johnson's far more challenging avoidance of obvious sequentiality.

17 comments:

Michael Kelleher, Buffalo, NY said...

I suppose a film almost always fails in comparison with the book from which it is adapted, but viewed apart from the book (which I haven't read) I thought it made a pretty successful contribution to the junky-film genre.

Ed Howard said...

Johnson's novel is undoubtedly far superior -- he's a fantastic writer, and a writer whose tendency towards introspection and abstraction makes his work difficult if not impossible to film -- but I always enjoyed MacLean's film too. It's heavily indebted to the book and doesn't stand apart as its own thing, but I thought it does a decent job of translating Johnson's prose into images. One that's stuck with me is the sequence of the guy with the Jesus tattoo; really haunting stuff.

小愛 said...

great.......................................................................

eliastaiken said...

一葉晴貼圖區,影音視訊聊天室,玩美女人,免費視訊,ut 聊天室,美女寫真,微風成人,玩美女人,同志交友,成人卡通,援交友留言,免費視訊,美女影片,情色視訊,伊莉成人,成人光碟,tt1069同志交友網,85cc成人片,新人淚成人色網,日本美女寫真集,免費聊天,聊天室080,999成人性站,av成人網,情色貼圖區,情色論壇,成人聊天室,視訊美女,同志貼圖,成人視訊,視訊交友90739,視訊聊天室,比基尼泳裝美女,杜雷斯成人,色情影片,免費視訊,交友戀愛進行室,玩美女人,美女交友,正妹時鐘,

tannahans said...

外表往往與事實本身不符,世人卻容易被表面裝飾所欺騙了..................................................

nicky said...

hello........................................

簡單 said...

快樂與滿足的秘訣,就在全心全意投注於現在的每一分,每一秒上..................................................

知道 said...

睇完之後覺得有d頓悟..感謝分享.........................................

時尚 said...

感覺很好的blog,祝你開心喔..................................................

淑君淑君 said...

色情a片瑤瑤寫真集天空交友完美女人免費女優電影正妹牆強力版正妹牆帶回家正妹牆成人網正妹貼圖區250av女優免費影片日本女傭介紹日本女優 mms4u日本女優a片日本女優a片網站日本女優av日本女優無碼免費下載日本女優裸照日本女優貼圖區日本女優光碟日本好玩免費線上遊戲美女 視訊免費聊天66k日本a電影免費一葉情貼影片區a圖打飛機專用網情色cu成人bt入口sod特輯真人娃娃免費性愛影片免費h影片成人光碟一葉情貼圖片區 av12720jack主入口0204成人人妻凌辱參觀日南部成人聊天室曼雪兒-情色文學 免費成人小說更衣室偷拍短片更衣室偷拍影片更多18禁小遊戲更多色情小遊戲

于名于名 said...

hello~~........................................

林昀睿 said...

秋去冬來~~大家要注意身體,別感冒囉! ..................................................

曾嘉慧 said...

傻氣的人喜歡給心 雖然每次都被笑了卻得到了別人的心......................................................

佩昭彥怡 said...

聰明的人喜歡猜心 雖然每次都猜對了卻失去了自己的心......................................................

鈺禎 said...

t 台灣藝術台辣妹有約 辣妹情色視訊 辣妹性感 辣妹影音聊天網 聊天室環球辣妹34c聊天室 辣妹亞洲成人圖片區 辣妹有約溫泉 辣妹性愛文學 辣妹哈啦聊天室 辣妹貼圖a片天堂 辣妹自拍偷拍 辣妹聊天室 90691比基尼辣妹影片 超性感辣妹 視訊情人辣妹080 視訊辣妹援交女 視訊辣妹援交 視訊辣妹自慰 視訊辣妹34c甜心寶貝直播貼片 視訊辣妹080 視訊辣妹,成人,嘉義視訊 aio性感辣妹34c甜心寶貝貼片 aio辣妹交友愛情館 aaio辣妹視訊 比基尼av辣妹影片 辣妹聊天室90691 辣妹影音 辣妹貼圖站 本土美少女辣妹貼圖 辣妹有約綜藝節目 辣妹貼圖站 辣妹情色網 情色視訊交友辣妹no3 性感辣妹交友 脫衣亞洲辣妹 玩美辣妹有約 環球辣妹聊天室 視訊辣妹34c 辣妹妹影音視訊聊天室 兼職援交友辣妹視訊 高雄辣妹視訊 桃園辣妹視訊 台北辣妹視訊 台中辣妹視訊 名模辣妹聊天室 885cc 85cc成人片試看 85cc女 85cc免費影城85cc免費影城 85cc免費影片觀賞 85cc免費影片短片 85cc自拍 85cc無碼影 85cc 亞洲短片 a交友愛情館影片免費85cc

雲亨 said...

感覺很用心經營呢!鼓勵鼓勵........................................

GenovevaPer32669 said...

Well done!........................................